What a Matchmaker Notices in the First Five Minutes

Most of the time, we know within the first few minutes of sitting down with someone whether what they're telling us matches what we're actually seeing. just paying attention to something everyone's brain already does automatically tells you a lot. Someone will tell us they're easygoing, that nothing really gets to them, and their leg hasn't stopped bouncing since they sat down. This pattern shows up all the time, and when it does, the body's almost always the one telling the truth.

Eye contact is the thing clients ask us about most, so we'll start there. A study out of the Archives of Sexual Behavior tracked real speed dates using eye-tracking equipment, 240 of them, and found people were more likely to pick partners they'd shared more mutual eye contact with, even once researchers accounted for how attractive that person was rated separately. But the amount of eye contact someone gives isn't really what we're looking at. It's whether it feels natural, rising and falling with the conversation the way it would if someone's engaged and enjoying the conversation, or whether it feels held on purpose or forced, like they read somewhere that eye contact matters and are now performing it right at us.

The gap between between someone's words and their body language is where the real story lives. Someone can call themselves relaxed while their arms stay crossed the entire time we're talking, and we're going to trust the arms. This isn't some special skill on our part either, there's research behind how fast people size each other up. A study out of Psychological Science found people form judgments about a stranger's trustworthiness in around 100 milliseconds, faster than anyone could consciously decide to think it. So really, we're all doing this constantly. We've just spent years learning to notice it deliberately instead of letting it happen in the background and forgetting about it five seconds later.

‍

‍

A Few More Things We're Weighing

Tone of voice is another one, and it might matter more than posture, since it's harder to control over the course of a full conversation. Someone whose voice stays completely flat while describing something they swear excites them is telling us something, whether they mean to or not, and the opposite is just as loud, real excitement tends to change how fast and how high someone's voice gets without them trying to make it happen. We're also listening for how a conversation moves. Does someone ask real follow-up questions, or are they just waiting their turn to talk again? That kind of curiosity tends to be a better predictor of how someone treats a partner than anything they could put on paper.

And then there's the old one that still holds up every time, how someone treats the people around them who have nothing to do with why we're all sitting there. A server, a receptionist, whoever happens to walk by. That's a much harder thing to fake than a firm handshake or a well-timed smile, and it's told us more about character over the years than almost anything else on this list.

These are all things we are actively looking for, in that first real conversation, while a client's telling us what they're hoping to find, and we're taking in everything else at the same time, how they're sitting, how fast they're talking, whether they loosen up or tense depending on what we've just asked. We build the search around all of it, what someone says they want, and everything else they've shown us without meaning to.

‍

‍

Wondering What We'd Pick Up On With You?

The best way to see it in action is to come sit down with us yourself. Get started here.

‍

FAQs

Is eye contact really that important on a first date?

Yes, but its not the most important factor. A 2024 speed-dating study found people were more likely to choose partners they'd shared more eye contact with, though the pattern of it matters more than the sheer amount.

How fast do people form first impressions?

Research published in Psychological Science found that trustworthiness judgments can form in as little as 100 milliseconds, before there's time to consciously think it through.

Can someone train themselves into giving off a better first impression?

To a point, though it tends to work better from the inside out. Real interest in the person across the table produces most of the signals people try to perform on purpose anyway.

Do you read people the same way a date would?

Largely, yes. We're picking up on the same things anyone might notice on instinct, we've just spent years learning to pay closer attention to it.

What's the clearest sign someone's checked out on a date?

A wandering phone or a wandering gaze. Both register as disengagement even when they feel small in the moment.